Tanker accidents are too frequent

If someone had three car accidents in three years, I'd be worried.


Re: Mountians out of mole hills, July 30 Northern View.

“You can’t point to the grounding of the Amakusa Island as a reason to oppose tanker traffic anymore than you can point to a fender-bender as a reason not to drive”.

If someone had three car accidents in three years, I’d be worried.

The port, while planning for the possibility of an oil terminal on Ridley Island, recently had a risk assessment done which gave predictions for “oil spills” and for “incidents”.  “Incidents” are basically freighter fender-benders. They got it so wrong that some people can’t help but smile when they look at the half sunk Amakusa Island. One woman on the Atlin dock winked at me and pointed: “That’s impossible!”

“Based on current traffic levels and vessel mix, and after adjusting for local factors, a commercial vessel incident could be expected at a frequency of once every 23 years” reads the Prince Rupert Port Authority Marine Risk Assessment.

Is it possible that this “one in 23 years” prediction is correct? In January 2012 the container ship, the Cosco Yokohama was hit by a rogue wave in Dixon Entrance. It nearly capsized and lost containers overboard.

In November 2012 the Hanjin Geneva grounded while piloted and though not officially escorted, a tugboat was only minutes away. Now in July 2014, the Amakusa with two pilots on board hit bottom, tore a gash in the hull and took on water.

The chances of tossing heads three times in a row are half-by-half-by-half. So a very rough estimate of the odds of these three Rupert commercial shipping incidents would be 1 /23 x 1 /23 x 1 /23 That works out to one chance in 12,000 or pretty well impossible – if the port’s risk assessment is right.

If those who want an oil terminal in Prince Rupert think their neighbours are fear mongering and not good at understanding the odds, maybe they should take a closer look at that assessment report. The adjustment for local factors seems to have put it out by a whopping factor of 10 times.

It has further serious under-estimations; it doesn’t include incidents at anchorage, it underestimates the probable number of tankers compared to full operation at an oil terminal and it uses a highly optimistic estimate of the value of tethered tugs and pilots.

Worse yet it doesn’t consider spills at the terminal itself, which account for a third of oil spills which in this case would be right in the Skeena estuary.

Luanne Roth

T. Buck Suzuki Environmental Foundation

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Aimed at success – the launch hit the target

Prince Rupert teen Brendan Eshom launches educational software app that hits Apple’s “Top Charts”

Getting a head for cancer research

Prince Rupert Cops for Cancer want to flush away the illness with loads of donations for research

Provincial COVID-19 data can now be used for B.C. to prepare for a second wave

In the past week, B.C. has seen a slight spike in daily test-positive case counts

Four air ambulance flights out of Terrace delayed or cancelled

Pandemic precautions caused nighttime closure of service station providing weather data to pilots

Skeena Resources, Tahltan prez excited by purchase of Eskay Creek

Skeena gets full control of mine, Barrick gets 12 per cent of Skeena and a one per cent royalty

Recent surge in COVID-19 cases not unexpected amid Phase Three of reopening: B.C.’s top doc

Keep circles small, wear masks and be aware of symptoms, Dr. Bonnie Henry says

B.C. NDP changing WorkSafeBC regulations to respond to COVID-19

Employers say reclassifying coronavirus could be ‘ruinous’

Baby raccoon rescued from 10-foot deep drainage pipe on Vancouver Island

‘Its cries were loud, pitiful and heartbreaking,’ Saanich animal control officer says

Statistical flaws led to B.C. wolf cull which didn’t save endangered caribou as estimated

Study finds statistical flaws in an influential 2019 report supporting a wolf cull

Windows broken, racist graffiti left on Okanagan home

Family says nothing like this has happened since they moved to Summerland in 1980s

B.C. man who went by ‘Doctor Ray Gaglardi’ charged with sex assault of teenage boys

The man, 75, is accused of assaulting teenage boys he met through Coquitlam-area churches

B.C.’s potential deficit $12.5 billion as spending spikes, taxes drop

Finance Minister Carole James gives COVID-19 outlook

Canadians torn on scaling back COVID-19 benefits to save money: poll

Of those surveyed, 78 per cent said they were worried about the size of the deficit

‘Trauma equals addiction’: Why some seek solace in illicit drugs

Part 2: Many pushed into addiction by ‘toxic stress,’ says White Rock psychologist

Most Read