Gerald Stewart and other pipeline opponents stay behind after Joint Review Panel hearing ends to discuss what they should do now.

Pipeline opposition says intervenors ‘muzzled’ at Enbridge hearings in Prince Rupert

Rules on presenting oral evidence at Enbridge hearings rankle some pipeline opponents enough to look for a new way to fight the project.

The Joint Review Panel hearings in Prince Rupert on the proposed Enbridge Northern Gateway pipeline are over, and many are feeling disillusioned with the process. Not even an hour had passed after it ended before a public meeting was organized for Februrary 28 to come up with a better way than regulatory hearings to oppose the pipeline.

The Joint Review Panel in Prince Rupert was the first opportunity for interveners to give oral evidence to the three person panel who will be making a recommendation to the federal cabinet on whether the pipeline should be allowed to go ahead. Many were saying that testimony had been “muzzled” as interveners were not allowed to explicitly argue against the project or present any technical information on the environment or anything else.

When the hearings concluded after a presentation by the Allied Fishermen and Workers Union, many people filed out and left but some stayed behind to talk about what they had just witnessed.

Angriest of all was Gerald Sewart of the Gitsis who walked into the middle of the room and said that opponents of the pipeline had gone along with the hearing process long enough, and now they need to unify and refine their message to fight pipeline proponents in the political and media realms. Otherwise, he said, the federal government will just go ahead with it no matter what is said at hearings.

“If it’s well orchestrated and we take all the best speakers we have and all the scientific data; we need to put together our own media package too. There’s a lot of knowledge here, there’s a lot of people who do Internet-ing. We skirted along it but no one was actually allowed to say [ arguments against the pipeline] , ‘oh, we don’t want to talk about that,’” Stewart told the room.

The reason why intervenors were not allowed to make arguments against the pipeline was because it didn’t count as oral evidence. According to the energy board’s rules, oral evidence can only be the speaker’s own experiences and opinions that illustrate how the pipeline could affect the region if it were to go ahead.

Speakers were not allowed to actually argue against the pipeline. If a speaker uttered the words “if there is a spill…” Enbridge’s lawyer would make an objection saying that it was argumentative. And the panel’s chairperson would remind the speaker save those thoughts for the closing arguments in April. The same went for any kind of technical or scientific data, political statements, or arguing against any specifics of the pipeline plan.

The rules made for some odd testimony as speakers were basically trying to layout reasons for why the pipeline should not go ahead without ever talking directly about the pipeline or the tankers.

Local MP, Nathan Cullen, was the first speaker of the hearings and the first one to come into conflict with the procedural rules about oral evidence. Almost immediately after the politician began, Enbridge’s lawyer objected to the political nature of his evidence, that he was arguing specifics of the pipeline and not sticking to his own personal experiences.

After an hour of arguing with the panel on what he could and could not say, the hearings took a five minute break. After it reconvened, Cullen told a couple anecdotes about him living in northern BC and his experiences traveling the region as an MP. It lasted about 10 minutes.

In the convention centre after the hearings, Gerald Stewart’s call for a more organized, more overtly political opposition to the pipeline went over well with the small group of people in the hearing room as more, and more people filtered back in from the lobby to listen.

“Well, my job is organizing,” announces fishermen’s union representative and city councillor, Joy Thorkelson,” so, we’re going to have a meeting at Fishermen’s Hall . . .we’ll do it on Tuesday the 28th at 7:00 and everyone is welcome.

Thorkelson agrees that it’s time to for the opposition to stop organizing independently and come up with a plan to fight the pipeline in the media and online. The meeting at the Fisherman’s Hall, she says, will be for getting people together and developing some kind of plan based on people’s strengths.

“We’ve been around this for a long time. We can win this thing. This will be won on politics. . . It’s not going to be won no matter how heartfelt and how many tears were shed up front there. That’s not what’s going to make a difference. The difference is political,” says Thorkelson.

The Prince Rupert Northern View tried to interview a representative from Enbridge to get their thoughts on what was said at the hearings, but company’s group left the hearing room and the building as soon as the hearings ended.


Just Posted

Council briefs: NWCC to stop ESL courses, financial bylaw adopted

Notes from the April 23 Prince Rupert city council meeting

City to begin jail cell upgrades by mid-May

Cost of the Prince Rupert cell project to cost more than $456,800

Prince Rupert Amateur Swim Club makes waves in Prince George

The Prince Rupert Amateur Swim competed in Prince George April 20-22

Richard Haley wins BC Web squash tournament for fourth time

Prince Rupert squash club competes in Smithers

Running in memory of Tamara

Team “Tears to HOPE” ran in the Vancouver Sun Run in honour of murdered and missing Indigenous women

Prince Rupert’s first adaptive hiking program launched

Kaien Coastal Riders have secured a TrailRider to make the North Coast outdoors more accessible

How to keep local news visible in your Facebook feed

Facebook has changed the news feed to emphasize personal connections. You might see less news.

Doctor sees healing power in psychedelic plant as Peru investigates death of B.C. man

Peru’s attorney general has ordered the arrest of two suspects in the killing of 41-year-old Sebastian Woodroffe

Toronto police officer ‘gave himself the space and time’ in van attack

Footage shows officer standing up, turning off his siren and talking clearly to the suspect

$1.18 to $1.58 a litre: Are you paying the most for gas in B.C.?

Gas prices across B.C. vary, with lowest in Vernon and highest in – you guessed it – Metro Vancouver

Inquest set 10 years after B.C. woman shot, left to die

Lisa Dudley, and her partner, Guthrie McKay were shot in their Mission home in September 2008

B.C. hockey team to retire Humboldt Bronco victim’s number

BCHL’s Surrey Eagles to retire Jaxon Joseph’s No. 10 in light of bus tragedy

B.C. Hells Angels invited to rally by anti-SOGI organizer

The Culture Guard group has helped Hells Angels in the past, said its executive director.

B.C. bill aims to keep Indigenous kids in communities, out of care

Changes to Child, Family and Community Service Act could connect MCFD, Indigenous communities

Most Read